Maloney, who represents parts of Manhattan and Queens in the House, is one of the leaders in Congress in fighting for the health of 9/11 workers and rescuers who lacked adequate safety equipment. She stands up for the 60,000 people who pitched in at Ground Zero, more than half of whom report serious respiratory and other health problems to this day.
Knowing OSHA’s poor track record at enforcing laws during times of crisis, like the 9/11 cleanup, Maloney saw the situation unfolding in the Gulf and spoke out about the need to protect the health of cleanup workers, as she put it, “before they lose it.” Maloney said on the floor of the House this morning:

The BP oil spill has caused a great emergency along our Gulf Coast. I hope as the response to it continues, we never forget the lessons of the Ground Zero workers. In the wake of 9/11, thousands of men and women labored tirelessly. Driven by a sense of urgent purpose, safety precautions were not taken, and assurances were given that proved to be false. The health of far too many of those who worked on that toxic pile, they suffered long-term health consequences.
Now in the Gulf, men and women are once again being exposed to a toxic sea of elements. After just 40-some days, there are already reports that workers have suffered exposure to the oil, and this cleanup will go on for years. The time to address the issue of the health of the cleanup workers is now, before they lose it.
Maloney knows that in the days, weeks, and months following 9/11, people in lower Manhattan were at risk of serious health issues due to poor air quality and asbestos from the fallen buildings. Despite pleas from local authorities, members of Congress, and the workers themselves, OSHA and EPA refused to require workers use respirators and other personal protection equipment to protect their health. Dr. Kirk Murphy at the Seminal pointed us to what happened, or didn’t, after 9/11:
With regard to the Ground Zero clean-up, the FOIA request uncovered a trail of email and other documents showing that the New York City Department of Health (NYCDOH), the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the New York City Fire Department (NYCFD) all asked for OSHA enforcement during October 2001 when the immediate crisis had passed and extensive clean-up efforts were underway. Despite requests, OSHA did not enforce its regulations. It is estimated that as many as 60,000 workers and volunteers assisted in the clean-up. Though no one knows what portion failed to use proper PPE, anecdotal reports suggest that unsafe exposure was commonplace. Already, as many as 60 percent of all Ground Zero workers have shown some signs of respiratory illness and some have died due to their exposure.
OSHA needs to conduct a monitoring program independent of the recovery effort of BP and the Coast Guard. We need to know every data point of air monitoring in the region. We need to know the safety training for workers gives them the knowledge they need to recognize risks to their health. And we need to know workers have every available piece of personal protection equipment, including respirators, that they need to work safely with the cleanup of BP’s oil. If we don’t act now, and if OSHA continues to provide cover for BP, Gulf cleanup workers will suffer for the rest of the lives, and BP will wash its hands thanks to the complicity of OSHA.
FDL activist Spocko wrote an action diary calling for respirators for BP cleanup workers. Be sure to read his call to action, and then join his Facebook group in support of respirators for workers.



29 Comments









Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Work in Progress
Jane is expected on MSNBC’s Ratigan at 4:30 pm EDT or so today.
Gee, I wonder what they will discuss today?
meanwhile . . . another captive ‘progressive’, Hilda Solis is tweeting
“Safety of workers top priority”
Sternly worded speeches from Maloney. Where was she when it mattered for 9/11 cleanup workers.
Saw that. She’s with OSHA head who said no need for respirators. Unfortunately, they’ll see nothing of the real cleanup. It’ll always be cleanup theater.
I want some officials to go in disguise, a la Peter the Great, to get the real story for what’s happening with workers and cleanup.
Um, all over it? She’s done a ton since 9/11 to fight for their health and their compensation for workers.
I forgot: cue up the kabuki hearings, but my no means make sure any protective gear gets to workers in real time when it matters.
Protective gear for 9/11 workers? Helmut liners for soldiers? Reinforced vehicles for soldiers? Protective gear for oil cleanup workers? Theme here.
So what has she actually accomplished? How much money has she gotten for them?
Besides, I wasn’t talking about long after the fact; I was talking about what she did/n’t do in real time when it would have mattered.
woot – Jane just said the R word on the teevee.
meanwhile I got $10 that CAP gal mentions Cheney
disappointing that Ratigan just set up the whole Cheney did it ! meme
While we’re on the subject of 9/11, anyone know how much of the (I forget was it $10 or $20) billions NYC was promised by the USG that it actually got? I missed the final accounting.
Dr David Michaels – you can run, but you can’t hide
okay, I lost the $10 – gladly. however, I believe she refrained because she might have had a clue as to what Jane would have done with it :D
hearings have been somewhat effective and forcing the hands of BP and agencies, particularly with the use of dispersants. They’re not real action, but they help bring things into the light that could use attention.
http://emptywheel.firedoglake.com/2010/05/20/congress-gets-results-on-corexit/
Congress and government acts slow. We’re in a bad position now that OSHA is already capitulating to BP and saying respirators aren’t necessary.
But Congress has oversight of OSHA, and as more attention is brought to this issue, OSHA’s hand can be forced.
It sucks. Don’t get me wrong. But it’s better to have someone saying this inside Congress than not at all.
Oh man…if only they could do an hour-long program like Undercover Boss.
It’s almost hilarious in a macabre sort of way. How utterly absurd. What is so difficult about just giving those workers protective equipment from the start and then there’ll be no need for outrage, slow deaths and compensation claims later. But no. Of course, there is a reason. The reason is the regulations on health checks that apply when someone is wearing protective equipment while doing a job. And that is the real issue here, and does this woman address that issue at any point? That the corporation is doing this because it wants to avoid complying with a few extra regulations about worker health and safety? This is a theatre of the absurd. She may only have a few minutes to speak, but she has enough time to name the real reason this is happening.
it was $20 – $5b was tax breaks that i believe weren’t used.
here’s some numbers from NYC on specific programs
http://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/wtc/html/background/funding.shtml
the 9/11 workers would be the perfect undercover folks – TradMed wouldn’t be able to dismiss them as “fringe” or “radical environmentalists”
I went to her ‘Town Hall’ in whenever-it-was, maybe April. Thought she was a thorough bitch; very bad tempered. Made sure the meeting was organized so that voters had no time for Q&A. She had maybe 7 speakers, all allegedly to talk about jobs. Not a single labor leader. Wouldn’t believe a word out of her mouth.
Thanks for the link.
you’re in NYC? i’m in brooklyn
I would add to that statement by saying that we need to Freeze BP assets now, before it’s too late. Get while the gettin’ is (marginally) good.
I knew Bush was stupid.
I knew Obama was smart.
Now I know that it is pointless to vote because no matter who is elected president the crap goes on.
This is why things happen:
The parliamentary battle of the NSDAP had the single purpose of destroying the parliamentary system from within through its own methods. It was necessary above all to make formal use of the possibilities of the party-state system but to refuse real cooperation and thereby to render the parliamentary system, which is by nature dependent upon the responsible cooperation of the opposition, incapable of action.
Ernst Rudolf Huber (witness)
From the Chief Counsel for the Prosecution of Axis Criminality
Volume I, Chapter VII
1946
http://thegallopingbeaver.blogspot.com/2010/06/bairds-of-this-world-get-away-with.html
Ahh, Adm. Thud (BP retired)
It’s a laugh a minute really. Obama, the man who made an impassioned speech (how many of those already hey?) about how science should be valued and scientists listened to. Except when their inconvenient facts, and theories get in the way of the Corporate Stoogie process.
So. Thud. Which is it? Your containment vessel is going to capture 1.17 million gallons a day, and that still won’t be all of it, and it’s currently only managing 630,000, but the flow was 500,000 – 1 million per day up until now, for corporate accounting / civil fines purposes?
You actually don’t even see the problem, do you Admiral? Numbers never your strong point were they? How’d you manage to navigate then? No, don’t answer.
You inhabit a parallel universe, Adm. Thud.
If the big O were a leader, he would be down in the Gulf, handing out respirators to oil workers. And he would have made it clear by now that BP would never again pump oil in US waters if it failed to clean up, pay up and shut up.
But no. We’ve got some perfidious wimp who unconvincingly talks about ‘kicking ass’ but will never do it. And BP remains in charge. And puts on its web site what it wants us to know. And the beat goes on.
IMHO it might be helpful to think of the transformation of a corrupt and ossified political and economic system as tantamount to the elimination of apartheid. Both had/have entrenched elites that had the power of the state at their disposal to suppress and quell any and all opposition. Both had/have elites that benefit at the expense of the majority. For the most part the elites in S.A. had a corrupt and complicit media willing to act as a filter of the “truth” and a conduit of propaganda. Are not the elites in the U.S. so blessed? The destruction of apartheid took years of organization, mobilization, protest and sacrifice. The loss of life on both sides was inevitable given the fact that power is never surrendered willingly. It’s time for the U.S. public, the working class, the middle class, the average Jane and John Doe to be prepared.
Obama is nothing more than the U.S. version DeKlerk with his finger in the dike trying to hold back the tide of history.
Thanks for the mention Michael.
Today I wrote the head of communications for the American Lung Association suggesting they step in now.
Catherine Sebold
American Lung Association:
Hi Catherine:
I read your letter to Secretary of Labor, Hilda Solis.regarding the lack of respirators to protect the respiratory health of workers on the oil clean up.
Two questions:
* Have you heard anything back?
* While waiting for the EPA to have more testing stations that will prove a toxic environment, are you taking any aggressive actions to protect the lungs of workers?
For example, is the American Lung Association considering purchasing and handing out quality respirators to workers in advance of eventual EPA rulings that the air is toxic? Are you going to be the group that prevents illnesses now vs. being mentioned in future lawsuits as someone who provided warnings and strong letters?
My Facebook group, BP, We Demand Respirators for ALL Clean Up Workers
has 276 members who care about workers getting respirators. I’m sure you have a lot more people who care about the health of lungs in general. Maybe some of your donors could be willing to fund a “Give an Oil Clean Up Worker a Respirator” program as part of your “Fighting for Air” campaign.
Your letter showed great insight into the potential health problems of this spill and the dispersant Corexit. You also seem to understand the bureaucracy issues that will delay worker protection. I think some action from the “leading organization working to save lives by improving lung health” would be swell right about now.
I’m eager to hear about your future plans.
LLAP,
Michal Spocko
P.S. When I saw those oil-covered birds I thought of the inside of a human’s oil covered lung.
cc.
American Lung Association
Charles D. Connor, President and Chief Executive Officer
Mary Partridge, National Board Chair
Janice Nolen, Assistant Vice President, National Policy and Advocacy
Norman H. Edelman, M.D., Chief Medical Officer
Media, Experts and Residents of Gulf Coast
Noaki Schwartz and Matthew Brown, Associated Press
Elisabeth Weiss, Science editor, USA Today
Michael Whitney, Fire Dog Lake
Riki Ott, author, Not One Drop – Betrayal and Courage in the Wake of the Exxon Valdez Oil Spill
George Williams, NOLA resident, admin BP, We Demand Respirators for ALL Clean Up Workers
Excellent group Spocko, I joined.
I think every-one who has any say in this needs to be asked (and be answered honestly).. ‘Would you send your son/daughter out to work on the clean-up, without the equipment to protect their health, whilst breathing all that crap in?