Hundreds of workers in the Gulf Coast cleaning up BP’s oil disaster have reported symptoms of nausea, vomiting, nose bleeds, and headaches, but those “almost all have been heat related,” according to Deputy Assistant Secretary of Labor for OSHA Jordan Barab.
Barab – a former worker health and safety blogger at Firedoglake and his blog, Confined Space – says that despite widespread assumptions that workers are sick from exposure to oil, “we haven’t really found that yet.”
“We’re really looking, but haven’t found anything significant in the chemical samplings. We’re looking for people getting sick, but it tends to be overwhelmingly heat related,” Barab told Firedoglake earlier this week.
In late June, OSHA issued guidelines for worker health and safety in the Gulf, including the limited use of respirators for workers around exposed crude oil near the source of the oil gusher. This came after more than 28,000 Firedoglake activists called on BP to provide respirators for cleanup workers.
OSHA has up to 40 employees in the Gulf Coast dedicated to the oil disaster, and have conducted more than 2,000 worksite visits. Barab says the challenges OSHA faces in the Gulf are similar to those of any other workplace for which the agency is responsible, namely that they can’t be everywhere at once.
“OSHA will never be in every workplace with every worker at every moment,” said Barab. “So we’re forced to do representative sampling. We characterize work situations and do as much sampling as we can. We’re hoping that those are representative.”
While OSHA is conducting its own evaluations of worker health through site visits, agencies in states and the federal government are cobbling together reports from emergency rooms and poison control centers, as well as BP’s own reporting, that paint a dire picture of worker safety.
According to data from the Louisana Office of Public Health analyzed by Firedoglake, more than 100 workers have reported symptoms similar to that of oil exposure. More than half (59) of workers reporting health symptoms were working offshore when exposed, which is where the most concentrated oil is found in the Gulf.
Barab says Louisiana’s data is misleading. Louisiana is “cataloguing, not describing” its data, which makes it look like people are sick from oil exposure, when in fact, according to OSHA’s analyses, most workers are actually sick from heat. NIOSH, part of the CDC, is working with Louisiana to include “more precises causes” for illnesses reported in its data.
OSHA says that “workers are supposed to be reporting symptoms.” While there have been reports that workers are holding back information for fear of being fired, OSHA is doing what it can to ensure workers are protected and that they know they can freely and confidentially report any problem.
As for BP’s cooperation on worker safety, OSHA is satisfied – much more than when OSHA’s head, David Michaels, complained of BP’s lack of effort on the topic in late May. ”At this point, we’re getting along fairly well with BP. Even though a lot of what we’re aksing them to do we dont have standards for, BP is pretty much doing what they want them to do,” said Barab. “When they’re not, with a little pressure, they do it.”
Any problems with worker safety in the Gulf are actually “with people who see this as another 9/11, another World Trade Center,” said Barab. “The issues are not between us and BP.”



48 Comments









Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Work in Progress
I have to say I find this post disheartening. I want to file it under the category: “Who are you going to believe, us or your lying eyes?”
In other news boldprogressives.org has launched a campaign to demand respirators it’s titled “BP Makes Me Sick”
I guess “Working For BP Might Cause Heat Related Illness” was not available.
Thanks for the info, Michael. Thank you, too, for all your hard work on this over the last 80-odd days.
I’ve noticed a sharp decline in media coverage of this disaster over the last 2 weeks or so. Do you think MSM has just gotten tired of the story? Maybe people have just gotten used to the idea that there won’t be an immediate fix? What’s your take?
The workers’ symptoms as described in the press are consistent with both petroleum exposure and heat exhaustion/heat stroke. Unfortunately, protection against chemical exposure and against heat oppose each other. Chemical protective gear tends to be hot and sweaty under the best of conditions, let alone summer in the GoM.
I believe it. I have worked in the heat plenty and it will kill you if you let it. That said, no doubt exposure to toxic chemicals can make people sick as well.
So what will “Deputy Assistant Secretary of Labor for OSHA Jordan Barab” be saying in 20 years? Long-term “heat related” illness? You bet…
Saw a picture of a woman yesterday from La. whose legs from the knees down were covered in large red sores. Heat doesn’t do that.
Another government agency licks British Petroleum’s ass.
Rear Admiral Mary Landrieu, three days after the platform exploded and sank:
“No oil is escaping from the wellhead.”
I think BP has a roomful of PR flacks, working out these talking points, and then handing them to the USCG, NOAA, and now, OSHA, to echo like a bunch of trained parrots.
And, “getting along fairly well” with BP, is THE main thing. Let’s not lose sight of that.
I feel like such an extremist, having fantasies about armed Federal Marshalls making dawn raids on BP’s offices down there and frog-marching these shitheads off to eat on a metal tray for a few years.
Then I’m an extremist too. One who believes in Rule of Law, justice and other “quaint” concepts.
The dispersants alone will rip apart your lipids and make you cough up blood.
I was thinking about that this morning, and my guess is that once BP stopped trying idea after idea to cap the damn well, there was less pressing coverage: “Did it work? What’s next?” Now that we’re just supposed to accept it will continue unabated until at least August, there’s less of the in the moment coverage.
That’s my guess at least.
OSHA says they are not detecting any dispersant chemicals in the air near any toxic level at all.
Who are you gonna believe, a
BPOSHA spokesman, or your lying eyes?No doubt, heat is a problem. I find it curious though that it can be ALL attributed to heat and not a combination of heat/oil.
Just.Not.Credible.
Yes, I’ve been expecting this. I’ve spent some time on the Gulf Coast in summer and the heat and humidity can be hard to take WITHOUT the aggravating factor of protective clothing. It’s nearly impossible to stay properly hydrated when perspiration is literally pouring off of you in streams.
It must be miserable work, whatever they’re getting paid can’t possibly be enough.
Two other BP stories:
Workers attempting to clean up the worst oil spill in American history have another disaster on their hands — an economic disaster. According to TV station WDSU, crews expecting a monthly paycheck came up empty yesterday, as BP failed to meet its agreed payroll date. The lawyer representing hundreds of the workers says BP won’t tell him when their money will come, either.
http://www.wdsu.com/news/24178322/detail.html
The Department of Homeland Security has announced the government will assume control of the joint website between BP and various organizations in charge of providing information about the BP oil spill and recovery.
Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/blogs/beltway-confidential/Feds-to-take-control-of-BP-leak-website-97973299.html#ixzz0t7aY284V
It also costs a whole lot of extra money to put large crews on the scene, whereas it’s much cheaper to keep a skeleton crew (or nothing) on scene, while the “big guns” read copy from teleprompters in the studio. Further, with the threat of $40,000 fines and jailtime looming for doing, ya know, actual reporting, why push it, right? Fuckin’ MSM weasels.
Might not be reflected in lab tests but the combined effects of the heat, humidity, and oil fumes must be unbearable.
I was thinking along the same lines. Once BP said “Well, we’ll see if we can stop this thing in August”, the media didn’t have any more hot story. Yet another chapter in the book of our fucked up MSM, I guess.
wow, disheartening indeed – Barab has gone all in
one of the recurring aspects of this I keep reading -
there is no existing body of work out there on the effects of exposure to Oil and it’s attendant chemicals – (and gee, wonder how that happened) there are studies on only 7 of the last 33 major gushers – and believe those to be studies of the psychological effects. Plus it’s a commonly used out to say ‘there is no study’ – they are talking about Govt Sponsored or Govt. Performed study. clear as drilling mud, aint it ?
p.s. found myself reading from the Journal of Comparative Toxicology – I blame this Whitney fella :D
Harm to workers caused by chemical exposure might not become evident until years from now. I have a deep seated distrust of all government claims but I actually find this account more credible than most.
and by the way Jordan, would you mind drinking from this “representative sample” glass of water for me ? thanks
Think that’s because DHS is better at disinformation?
Bp and the government are doing their best to keep the media out and since ‘their man’ Obama is president there will be evey effort by the MSM to make sure that this spill never becomes “Obama’s Katrina.” The Department of Homeland Security is taking over BPs leak website to provide us with all we need to know. Who needs an inquistive media looking for the truth when we can all simply go to ‘bp.gov’ for the ‘truth’.
According to AP reporter Harry R. Weber:
“The Department of Homeland Security wants a one-stop shop for information that is completely overseen by the government as it settles into the long-haul of dealing with the response to the disaster. The U.S. Coast Guard falls under Homeland Security’s authority.
BP and the federal government are part of a unified command that is working together to try to contain the oil gusher, but the government has been directing BP at every turn.”
Thanks CBL :) Always good to have more minds on this.
correction on my 21 above -
should have said “there is no existing body of work out there on the long term effects of exposure to Oil and it’s attendant chemicals.
Call me skeptical, but I believe THAT is why Rachel Maddow is now reporting from Afghanistan instead of the GoM. (:>
What water? They’re talking about air, and Jordan breathed that air. I assume you’re trying to make a “gasland” reference, but ya know, not workin’ for me.
Symptoms are also similar to the flu. And food poisioning. But the benefit of using heat as the cause is people can say “oh yeah it’s hot there!”
If you don’t have monitoring at the worker level looking for the right chemicals using real time sampling of course there will be no evidence. And evidence is what we need because we live in a framework of “get sick the sue” vs “better safe than sorry” (the precautionary principle).
I saw this same crap from the FDA and the pet food companies when cats and dogs were getting sick from melamine in their food. “we’ll did the cat have kidney problems before?” if yes then they weren’t a good candidate as evidence for a court case that the melamine was killing it.
Did any of you watch the video of the wife of some of the fisherman workers? Did you hear some of the other causes they told her were to blame? “Too much PineSol on the ship that they stood in for days” GMAFB!
I’ve seen these defensive moves before they are designed to muddy the water for future lawsuits. And this is one way that “science” and the media’s need to defer to experts is exploited.
I would call this inability of the media to drill down into the excuses of the agencies to provide cover for the industry as another form of regulatory capture.
People are getting sick from chemicals that nobody is looking for and nobody has any record of because they wasn’t any recording equipment at the exact location. So absent proof “science” can be used to say, “probably heat stroke”. Of course maybe we could use science and look into the lungs of the sick workers. Too bad that science isn’t sensitive enough to reveal the impact of Volatol Organic Chemicals that evaporate. Or did they get lung samples? If so, then it is off the court to sue someone after the fact. Then it will be their experts against our experts.
So to blow a hole in this “heat related story” my expert tells me “Ask them if they were doing real time air quality monitoring at the worker’s level for all the chemicals (including Corexit 9527 whose ingredients were not even released until recently). They will either say “we don’t have that data, or we have the data from a ship far away and high above the water” or we have the data but it is proprietary of CTEH and will not be released.” or “the data shows multiple chemicals but they are all under threshold limits” to which you can say “and what tests have been done that show that multiple chemicals -under threshold hold limits-can make people sick? To which they will respond, “none”.
oops I meant
volatile organic compounds.
How do you do real time monitoring on every worker? The only stuff I know is for radiation. I’m sure there’s ways I just haven’t seen it.
http://www.zerohedge.com/article/samples-confirm-corexit-ingredients-gulf-spill-area-far-above-toxic-concentrations
Oh, but these samples were not tested by a BP-approved source, so you know, we must ignore the results.
I wonder if Barab and OSHA have an opinion on BP and the Coast Guard using Corexit even after the EPA has told them to stop?
This is one of the limitations of the monitoring plans that work against the workers. I spoke to the VP of the largest oil spill clean up company in the west coast. He provides monitoring for his workers that cover the areas they are working. And he said that he can’t count on the EPA to provide adequate coverage since they only do average monitoring over a wide area.
The point is that he is looking out for his workers first instead of waiting for them to possibly get sick and sue him. Or waiting for OSHA to tell him to provide PPE.
Citizen journalist has water & oil tested – very toxic:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4WJf14orY-I
Obviously shallow foolishness like Lindsay Lohan’s soap operatic theatrics and Lebron’s egotistic puffery are just waay more interesting and relevant to the MSM than one of the worst oil spills of all time whose effects will felt for generations.
I’m no doctor, but that’s the first time I’ve ever heard that nosebleeds can be heat related.
We do not know what human health effects might occur after long-term exposure to food and water contaminated with benzene. In animals, exposure to food or water contaminated with benzene can damage the blood and the immune system and can cause cancer.
Cancer is not something that will show up after a week of exposure to toxic chemicals – it can and does take years to form and cause its insidious damage. Telling the Gulf Locals to stay inside is not the answer…. the poison is everywhere, carried, as it were on the winds…….
http://just-me-in-t.blogspot.com/2010/07/there-is-no-danger-from-that-oil.html
Why would people who have been working on the coast or in the gulf their entire lives suddenly become so sensitive to the heat?
I grew up in New Orleans and never found it uncomfortable. I played outside all summer long. I have been gone a long time and am visiting now. I found it unbearable but the people around me are fine with the heat.
I used to work in 110F kitchens . . . small one’s.
We drank water like crazy, we were young, no one ever got sick.
Hell, we drank beer and wine coolers, and water, too.
We drank like fish, every shift . . . . . and put out great food, we were that good.
And this is in a dozen kitchens, over 15 years . . . same patterns. Same great foods and products.
I’ve also been backpacking at 23 years old and been heat struck up the side of a 12,000 peak at 10K feet, in sand, in summer after a night of insanity which included days of hitchhiking to get there, and a night of liquor, some ‘chemical fun’, and pot.
Worst experience of my life. My two fellow backpackers had sense to shade me, bag me, and feed me water and keep me awake from 3pm to midnight, when I pulled out of it. Dizzy, vomiting on every thing put into me, sweats, chills, vomits. For hours on end, I couldn’t hold down water. Then, I could.
I was young.
My personal opinion, there’s heat, there’s people that are not young, and ANY fucking one doing work on the beaches of the Gulf are exposed to heat, and exposed to horrible chems, gas, oil and Corexit wise.
You don’t go out in that without full chem clothing and protection . . . and you have to be in shape and drink tons of water and get shade often, too.
So, what’s worse? Chem’s or mama nature and ill equipped out of shape workers?
They go hand in hand.
But the bottom line is, BP is hiring and sending out out of shape workers with little protection equipment wise.
And they do it just for show, too, cuz there’s really NO serious cleanup being done. The work being done that these folks that are hired to do, is to pick up dead fish and birds and such, to cover up the damage.
And THOSE workers are expendable, and they are just trying to earn a living and will likely suffer and die for it.
As Exxon tells us . . . decades later, the death rate of cleanup workers/volunteers is what, 90% I thought I read somewhere? (sorry, no linky right now)
Michael hell of a post once again and thanks . . . comments are good to, as always from Pups.
Dawg help The People Of The Gulf, And The Gulf.
And all it’s species . . . . it’s looking grim as hell.
Thanks for your comment, too, Run, I’m not knocking anything you had to say . . . .
We hope on, huh . . .
Yeh, there’s a lot of us out here, ain’t there.
Good to see ya out in action hoss.
This whole ‘shitmire’ (trademark Tanbark) in the Gulf is as corrupted, sick, stupid, and failed as anything this country has done in decades after decades.
Only now, the planet’s at risk.
You can’t fix stupid . . . or corrupted, it seems.
The fucking coast guard, USAF, and USA are flying and aerial dispersing Corexit.
Tell me that shit, no matter WHERE they deploy it, don’t get in the wind and harm land based life (aside from all the other harm that shit does to the marine life and avarian life out there).
Pure fucking folly. A poisoning of the poison of gas and oil BP let loose upon us all.
Where the fuck is OSHA testing, a few hundreds inland? As described by many folks already in posts here at FDL/Seminal?
OSHA has failed us, the environment, and is complicit in the coverup of this disaster.
We live in a corporate run fascist existence and it ignores the damage done, and being done to humans and plants and sea life and all species under and over the sea.
Sad. Love your reports, thanks again, hoss . . . keep it coming.
Micheal, it’s not curious, it’s fucking OBVIOUS!
Keep a hard edge, please . . . sway to the worst, don’t compromise the worst, or the truth will be distilled and watered down by others.
YOU! YOU Michael, and many others, are on the front line.
You have an obligation to tell the truth, and if not sure, assume the worst, cuz that’s what BP and our Corporate Fascist System have brought to us, the worst.
Stand tall, firm, Michael, and don’t be afraid to do worst case scenario . . . trust yer guts, and report to us that it IS a gut feeling, we’ll respect that . . . . .
Don’t hide nuttin, don’t couch your thoughts.
We want the reality and your thoughts unfiltered.
At least I do. I depend on that, frankly.
And I thank you for your work, once again.
The heat, the chems, BP or what . . . . .
I’ve always appreciated your comments . . .
To what do you allude?
No shit, huh . . . . what weasels rip our flesh . . . .
In 1989 Exxon told the cleanup workers the same story, that the crude oil is not toxic. Some of us are living proof of the toxic exposure, and many others have died. Please view the YouTube video, and help get the message to Gulf residents, BP crude oil cleanup workers, and President Obama. Respirators need to be supplied to oil cleanup crews.
Thank you.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5M1J7U2GYA0
How do you know when TV news is lying? When the TV is not on mute.
However, the censorship is worse than the untruths. It’s not so much that they tell you bullshit its the shit that they don’t tell you at all.
Do the research. Crude oil is a mixture of hydrocarbons, among other things. Some of the components are carcinogenic organic compounds (e.g., Benzene). These (and the emulsifiers that have been added) can and will evaporate and fall in rain storms. Drinking water and air will contain toxins. The food supply will become contaminated. Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico fisheries will be destroyed. People may starve.
How much longer are you all going to mistake internet messaging one another for grassroots political activism?
Read Mario Savio’s Berkley Free Speech Movement statement and organize.