From early on in BP’s oil disaster, President Obama and the rest of the government’s command team have insisted that it is the government, not BP, that is calling the shots on all aspects of the disaster. While that’s always been a questionable claim, given BP’s tight grip on pretty much everything from cleanup, hiring, PR, and media, we have yet another example that shows BP with its hands on the reins.
Elana Schor, who’s been doing yeoman’s work on reporting about data in the BP oil disaster, published a new piece with Greenwire and the New York Times in which she reveals that OSHA and NIOSH have access to worker health data from BP and its coverup firm, CTEH, but are so far refusing to release the data.
“I don’t want to defend [BP's] charts,” OSHA chief David Michaels said in an interview. “We understand the concerns about measurements made by BP’s contractors, and so we therefore look at our own measurements and other agencies’ measurements. … At this point, we feel fairly confident that we’ve made the right protective decisions.”
OSHA’s analysis of raw BP testing data concluded that among the 20 percent of sampled workers exposed to 2-butoxyethanol, “the highest level measured was 0.8 ppm, and 90% of these were 0.2 ppm or less,” according to a statement from the agency. “Every measurement was well below the NIOSH recommended limit of 5.0 ppm.” [...]
Asked why OSHA and NIOSH — which have access to results to daily worker monitoring performed by private BP contractors — do not release those results to independent scientists and Gulf Coast advocates such as Rolfes, Michaels said his agency continues to lean on the embattled oil company.
“If they don’t [release worker testing data], we’ll consider releasing it ourselves,” Michaels said. “We’re doing the best we can and doing a tremendous amount of sampling. We’re in the field, we’re on the boats. If people see specific information they think is not included, we’ll try to get it to them.”
Not acceptable. If the federal government is truly in charge of this disaster, there should be no “leaning” required. BP and CTEH should release every bit of data to OSHA and NIOSH, who should make it available in as close to real time as possible on their websites. There are experts from organizations and online who can check this data, in addition to the sampling performed by the agencies. It’s in the best interest of the public and recovery workers to have this data released.
Remember, the data in question are that collected by notorious corporate disaster coverup firm CTEH. Earlier versions of this data revealed toxic dispersants in the air around 20% of offshore cleanup workers, and 15% of onshore workers.
This is a life and death matter for BP’s recovery workers. OSHA and NIOSH need to release this data in real time, as soon as possible.



16 Comments









Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Work in Progress
I’m with ya, even tho I support Michaels and Barab they have a LONG way to go in transparency. If they don’t create a transparent OSHA now they might not have the chance in 2 years.
Yep, this is an issue of transparency and of separating the agency from BP. If OSHA needs more resources to do the job that BP and CTEH are claiming to do, BP should pay. I want to help OSHA with this. But transparency is the first step.
Ack, so the government is a wholly owned subsidiary of BP after all?
Michael, you should win some sort of prize for incessantly covering this BP disaster. It’s reportage like this that put FDL on the map five years ago (the Plame leak and subsequent trial). I’d love to see you do a piece on a local TV station that did chemical tests on Gulf water and found that it was flammable. Yes, Gulf water actually blows up. Go to ABlog if you don’t believe me.
Anyway, I wanted to thank anyone and everyone who stopped by my place to help our Mrs. JP and me during our most recent and alarming difficulty. We’re not out of the woods, yet, but we understand that many, many others are hurting and our heartfelt thanks especially go out to those who gave while smarting themselves.
Excellent job Michael! The Gulf region as well the entire Nation should be giving you a big thank you for your tireless work on this issue.
A question Michael: In all your conversations with what I can imagine has been a broad spectrum of folks from many political persuasions, has anyone ever mentioned how we might directly and meaningfully pull the reins of power and deception from BP, as well as our own governmental agencies, and get some consistent movement that reflects unbribed scientific data and the will of the citizenry, and NOT the monied interests in all this? Just wondering…
just looking at Adm Allen’s latest, um, requests for both procedures and rov assets pretty much tells the barely conscious just who is in charge here
and allow me to again express my sincere thanks for all your work on this vitally important story, Michael
I am inclined to give OSHA, and DOL, the benefit of the doubt at this stage.
The entire DOL has suffered terribly from the abuse and neglect of the Bush years, and it is a huge job to get the organization back on an even keel.
I wrote a diary on all the agencies needing cleaning back in late ’08.
Labor was one of the many agencies and departments that suffered from Bush years.
It would help if Obama and company would actually fill the empty slots (through recess appointments if necessary) in all these areas and get Bush holdovers out of the picture.
When it comes to any agency or person/persons that willfully or out of sheer stupidity retain useful and validly important data that subsequently can mean the compromising of either the environment, or the living inhabitants that occupy that environment, as well as possibly causing said environment or living things to experience sickness or death…
…then no ‘benefit of doubt’ should be encouraged or granted. NO EXCUSES! That to me is paramount to saying ‘too bad someone will have to suffer for our lack of expertise and god damn incompetence’.And if it is Obama’s fault for not pushing hard enough to fill these positions with the mandate he was granted in 08, then kick his sorry ass out!
Hmmm…
Firstly, I would point out that nothing in Michael’s post that justifies the assumption that OSHA “willfully or out of sheer stupidity retain(s) useful and validly important data that subsequently can mean the compromising of either the environment, or the living inhabitants…”
Secondly, I would suggest you look to the source of the problem — namely BP. There is nothing in the world preventing BP from publishing the information that their contractor has gathered on BP’s behalf.
OSHA has access to the BP data
OSHA analyzes the BP data
OSHA can’t just release the data?
A confidentiality agreement over health and safety data that keeps it away from the public? Who the hell agreed to that? – Oh right – Obama.
So the government is afraid to take on the oil companies because they might leave the US and go some where else? Guess what dunnderhead, they’ve already gone. The best thing that could happen to the US right now is to be cut off from all oil supplies. Oil is poisoning peoples minds.
On your first account, I believe what I stated was:
.
I was not inferring that Michael’s post justified any particular assumption…I was actually replying as above to what seemed to me a justification on your behalf to give OSHA and DOL the ‘benefit of the doubt’…please clarify what exactly that benefit is please, because I just can’t see anybody justifying that unless you are part of the BP cabal!
Bruce on your second point I agree…the large cat who is eating all the mice IS BP!
http://www.kingworldnews.com/kingworldnews/Broadcast/Entries/2010/7/17_Matt_Simmons.html
Are you aware of this Matt Simmons interview on King World News?
Scary stuff.
I’m willing to give DOL/OSHA the benefit of the doubt because I see no reason whatsoever to believe that the agencies are part of the BP cabal, or are working against the interests of the people of the Gulf in any way. Instead, I see a weakened and unprepared bureaucracy scrambling to respond to an unexpected crisis.
And, no, I am not part of the BP cabal myself :)
…and you’ll go your way, and I’ll go mine. I still believe they are all incompetent and are incapable of truthfully revealing the facts for reasons that are entirely controlled by BP…and in that light THEY ARE working against the interests of the people of the Gulf and this country in regards to this epic disaster, and all your apologies that include an unexpected crisis comes across as pretty weak tea in my opinion!